Reviewer Form

Arul Anandar Journal of Science & Arts (AAJSA) • Manuscript Peer Review Assessment Form

SECTION A: GENERAL ASSESSMENT
Total Score: 0 / 35
Rating Scale: 5 – Excellent 4 – Very Good 3 – Good 2 – Average 1 – Poor
Criteria Score (1 to 5)
Originality of the Research *
Relevance to the Journal Scope *
Clarity and Organization *
Methodology and Analysis *
Validity of Results and Interpretation *
Quality of Figures, Tables, and References *
Contribution to the Field *
SECTION B: DETAILED COMMENTS

Detail constructive feedback, strengths, major revisions, or specific corrections needed. (This will be shared with the authors).

Confidential remarks, ethical concerns, or notes strictly for the Editor-in-Chief.

SECTION C: RECOMMENDATION
REVIEWER’S DETAILS

Declaration of Competing Interest of the Reviewer